migrationengagementplatforms

How to Move Your Group to a Friendlier, Paywall-Free Forum Without Losing Members

cconnects

2026-02-04

10 min read

A step-by-step playbook to move your group to a paywall-free forum—preserve members, streamline onboarding, and keep engagement high.

Move your support group to a paywall-free forum without losing members — a migration playbook inspired by Digg’s 2026 paywall-free beta

Feeling anxious about moving your group? You’re not alone. Community leaders and caregivers tell us the same fears: losing members, breaking years of threaded conversations, and facing a steep technical learning curve. The good news: in 2026, migrations are easier and more accepted than ever — especially to paywall-free forums that prioritize accessibility and trust. This playbook gives you a step-by-step plan to preserve engagement, manage onboarding, and set expectations — modeled on recent platform moves like Digg’s paywall-free beta and the broader push for open, discoverable communities.

Quick executive summary: What to do first (read this now)

Audit what you have — members, posts, files, moderators.
Pick the next-platform and validate it with a small pilot group.
Export data and back it up (members, threads, media, metadata).
Announce early with a clear communication plan and timeline.
Onboard members with frictionless invites, FAQs, and live help sessions.
Measure retention and iterate quickly in week 1–8.

Why 2026 is the right moment to go paywall-free

Late 2025 and early 2026 accelerated two trends that favor paywall-free community platforms: more mainstream alternatives to paywalled networks (Digg’s public, paywall-free beta being a headline example) and improved tooling for migrations, data portability, and AI-assisted onboarding. Social networks are experimenting with open discovery (e.g., Bluesky’s public features like Live Now and cashtags), while users are demanding accessible, stigma-free spaces for health, caregiving, and bereavement support.

“Digg’s public beta in January 2026 opened signups and removed paywalls, making discovery and community rebuilding simpler.”

That cultural shift matters for community leaders: moving to a paywall-free forum can increase growth and trust — as long as you manage the migration carefully.

Pre-migration: Plan and audit

Before you touch the export buttons, get clarity on scope, goals, and success metrics.

Stakeholder kickoff

Gather moderators, co-hosts, and power members for a 60–90 minute planning call.
Agree on goals: reduce churn by X%, keep top 10 threads, preserve media, etc.
Assign roles: Migration lead, Tech lead, Communications lead, Moderator lead.

Inventory checklist

Run a forensic inventory of your community. Here’s what to capture:

Member data: usernames, display names, emails (if you have consent), join date, roles, opt-ins.
Content: threads, pinned posts, top comments, attachments, media URLs.
Engagement metrics: DAU/MAU, top posters, weekly event attendance.
Integrations: webhooks, bots, third-party embeds (YouTube, Zoom, Stripe).
Legal: consent records, privacy settings, community TOS.

Data export checklist

Export everything you legally can. Treat exports as your safety net.

Members CSV (user ID, username, email, role, opt-in flags)
Threads dump (JSON preferred — includes timestamps, author IDs, post bodies)
Media archive (preserve file names and parent post IDs)
Attachment mapping (original URLs and captions)
Moderation logs and reports (for continuity)
Backups stored in at least two locations (cloud bucket + encrypted external drive)

Tip: If your current platform has a limited export interface, use authorized API access or a scheduled crawl (respect platform rules) to preserve content. Document rate limits, and don't overrun them during business hours.

Choose the right paywall-free platform

Not all paywall-free platforms are the same. Evaluate based on:

Discovery: public search and indexing help new members find you.
Accessibility: support for assistive tech, captioned media, multiple languages. See also design guidance for inclusive events.
Data portability: APIs, import tools, and export options.
Community tools: moderation controls, events, threaded conversations.
Costs and sustainability: can you support the community with memberships, sponsorships, or grants?

Communication plan: preserve trust and reduce churn

Members leave when they feel blindsided. A clear, empathetic communication plan is your retention engine.

Timing and cadence

Week -4: Tease change and benefits — invite feedback.
Week -3: Announce migration date, FAQ, and pilot signup.
Week -2 to 0: Run a pilot with 5–10% of members (moderators + active users).
Day 0: Official migration announcement, one-click invite link, and onboarding schedule.
Week 1: Welcome series and live Q&A sessions.
Weeks 2–8: Weekly check-ins, feature updates, and a retention review.

Channels to use

Email (for members who opted in)
In-platform pinned announcement
Private messages to moderators and power users
Live events (Zoom, livestream with Q&A)
Social posts and local meetup flyers

Announcement template (short)

Hi [Name], we’re moving to a friendlier, paywall-free forum on [Platform] on [Date]. This will keep the group open and searchable, improve discoverability for those seeking support, and let us offer free access to essential peer support. Click to preview and RSVP: [one-click link]. Questions? Join our live Q&A on [Date].

Practice transparency: explain why you’re moving, what members will lose (temporary things) and what they’ll gain (open access, better search, live events). Acknowledge concerns about privacy or commercialization up front.

Onboarding: make joining frictionless and human

Onboarding is where retention is won or lost. Keep it low-friction but personal.

Onboarding flow checklist

Invite email or in-platform banner with a one-click join link.
Welcome message from the lead moderator + AI-generated summary of “what’s new.”
Interactive guide or short video tour (2–3 minutes).
“First steps” checklist: introduce yourself, read community guidelines, join a welcome thread.
Assign a buddy (moderator or power member) for the first week.
Day 3: Prompt to attend a welcome live session; Day 7: Encourage first post with an easy prompt.

Use micro-commitments: ask new members for small, low-risk actions (like react to a post) before asking for a full introduction.

Engagement-preserving tactics

Strategies to keep activity high during and after the move:

Move & spotlight top threads: manually recreate or import the top 10–20 threads and pin them for easy discovery.
Transition events: host a “Ribbon Cutting” livestream and schedule weekly support meetups for the first month.
Power-user rituals: preserve moderator roles and give them honorary badges on the new platform.
Automated nudges: use email or in-platform notifications to remind lapsed members to return.
Maintain search visibility: keep public archives for a period so search engines and inbound links remain valid. See guidance on building a preserved landing page or one-page notice with a clear redirect using a no-code micro-site.

Preserve SEO and incoming links

If your old group had public pages, set up redirects or maintain an archive page with canonical links to the new platform. If redirects are impossible, create a preserved landing page that explains the move and links prominently to the new forum. This preserves inbound traffic and reduces confusion. For examples and conversion-first landing guidance, see Conversion‑First Local Website Playbook.

Moderator and power-user transition

Your moderators are relational capital. Keep them close.

Invite moderators early to the pilot and solicit feedback on rules and workflows.
Share moderation guides and technical admin training before launch.
Run a co-moderation window where old and new mods overlap for two weeks.
Document escalation paths and contact information for urgent issues.

Technical migration: export/import best practices

Technical migrations vary by platform. Here are durable best practices:

Preserve IDs and timestamps: keep original post timestamps and user IDs in metadata so context isn’t lost.
Media handling: bulk-download media and re-host on a CDN that your new platform supports; consider perceptual AI storage for large image archives (see options).
Markup conversion: convert legacy BBCode/Markdown formats into the new platform’s standard.
Incremental sync: do a staged import (pilot then full) to catch mapping issues early.
Rate limits & retries: script with exponential backoff to avoid API throttling.
Logs & verification: keep logs of successes and failures and run spot checks on random posts; keep backups in at least two locations (offline-first tooling helps here).

Pro tip: use generative AI to produce concise summaries of long threads so new members can catch up fast. In 2026, many platforms natively support AI-assisted thread summarization — use it to create “thread TL;DR” posts that link to full archived content.

Measure and iterate: KPIs to watch the first 8 weeks

Track these KPIs daily the first two weeks, then weekly through week 8:

Activation rate: % of invited members who log in within 7 days.
Retention: 30-day retention and week-over-week active members.
Time to first post: median time for new members to make their first contribution.
Event attendance: % of RSVPed members who attend live sessions.
Moderator response time: average time to respond to reports in week 1.
Sentiment: measure via short post-event pulse surveys and content sentiment analysis.

Monetization without paywalls: sustainable, ethical options

Going paywall-free doesn’t mean you can’t fund the community. Here are inclusive models that preserve access:

Voluntary memberships: small recurring value-adds (early event access, private AMA channels).
Workshops & classes: paid webinars or group coaching while keeping core forums free.
Sponsorships and grants: partner with aligned organizations for sponsored resources, clearly labelled.
Merch and donations: affordable goods or tip jars for members who can contribute.
Affiliate programs: vetted resources tied to care needs with transparent disclosure.

Case study: What Digg’s paywall-free beta teaches community leaders

Digg’s 2026 public beta removed paywalls and reopened signups, improving discovery and lowering friction for new users. Lessons you can apply:

Public betas reduce fear: try-launch small and be transparent about “beta” limitations.
Open signups increase discoverability: the fewer gates, the more organic growth.
Iterate publicly: collect public feedback and ship frequent small fixes.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

Lost emails or permissions: mitigate by asking members to re-opt-in and providing alternate invite links.
Broken embeds: pre-map and replace third-party embeds and notify members of any media gaps.
Moderation gap: ensure overlap of old and new moderators for at least two weeks.
Under-communication: prevent by over-communicating milestones and FAQ updates.
Monetization backlash: be explicit about what remains free and what is paid.

8-week sample timeline

Week -4: Audit + stakeholder kickoff.
Week -3: Communicate intent and open pilot signup.
Week -2: Pilot migration with moderators + key members.
Week -1: Finalize export/import scripts, rehearsal run.
Week 0: Launch migration, send invites, host kickoff event.
Week 1: Intensive onboarding drives and troubleshooting.
Weeks 2–4: Feature parity fixes, weekly AMA, migrate remaining content.
Weeks 5–8: Retention optimizations, monetization rollout for optional perks.

Final checklist: 10 concrete next steps

Create an inventory and export all data to two backups.
Run a pilot with moderators and 5–10% of active members.
Publish an empathetic announcement and FAQ at least 3 weeks out.
Create one-click invite links and a low-friction onboarding flow.
Host live welcome events in week 0 and week 1.
Recreate and pin the top 10 threads in the new forum.
Train moderators and schedule overlap days.
Preserve SEO with redirects or a preserved landing page.
Track activation, retention, and sentiment daily in week 1.
Plan optional monetization that keeps core access free. See our toolkit for forecasting community finances: forecasting and cash-flow tools.

Closing: Ready to move? Here’s how we help

Moving a support community is a relational act, not just a technical one. In 2026, the best migrations balance empathy, transparency, and rigorous technical planning. Use the playbook above to reduce churn, preserve trust, and grow accessibility by switching to a friendlier, paywall-free forum.

Next action: download our free 40-point migration checklist, join our monthly migration workshop, or book a 30-minute migration consult with our team to get a customized plan for your group.

Want this playbook as a printable checklist? Click to download and start your pilot this week.

connects

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.